Welcome to Argyle Jewelers

Babylon’s Trusted Jeweler Since 1988 — Custom Design, Engagement Rings & Fine Jewelry


Welcome to Argyle Jewelers, Babylon’s family-owned jewelry destination since 1988. For over 35 years, our team has helped Long Island couples and families find the perfect piece — from custom-designed engagement rings and wedding bands to fine jewelry, expert repairs, and certified appraisals. 

Whether you’re designing a one-of-a-kind ring, shopping for a meaningful gift, or looking to sell or appraise estate jewelry, our experienced jewelers provide honest guidance and exceptional craftsmanship. Located in the heart of Babylon Village on Deer Park Avenue, we proudly serve families across Suffolk County and Long Island. 

Custom Jewelry Design

Experts in Fine Jewelry


Whether you are looking for a specific brand, a unique piece like an argyle pink diamond, or a custom design, we will give you personal attention and outstanding service to ensure that you find exactly what you are looking for.

WATCHES

Wide Variety of Watches


Argyle Jewelers prides itself in its wide array of watches. You can also come in to get your bands polished and cleaned, free estimates on all watch repairs and battery replacements while you wait!

OUR PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

As you can see, we do it all!


Artboard 3 copy 7

FINE JEWELRY


Whether you are looking for a specific brand, a unique piece, a pink diamonds or a custom design, we will give you personal attention and outstanding service to ensure that you find exactly what you are looking for.

Artboard 3 copy 4

ENGAGEMENT RING


Purchasing your bridal jewelry or wedding bands is one of the most exciting and important decisions you will make. At Argyle Jewelers, we strive to put our customers first.

Artboard 3 copy 2

JEWELRY REPAIR


At Argyle Jewelers, we offer professional jewelry repair in Babylon NY to help you restore and maintain your favorite pieces so they look as beautiful as the day you purchased them.

Artboard 3

BUYING AND APPRAISALS


Argyle Jewelers is here to assist you with all of your buying and appraisal needs! Contact us to help you!

Artboard 3 copy 3

WOMEN’S WATCHES


Argyle Jewelers has unique and beautiful pieces on hand for all of your women’s jewelry needs. Show the lady in your life that you love her, whether it’s your wife, mom, girlfriend, sister, aunt, cousin, daughter, friend, or anyone else!

Artboard 3 copy

MEN’S WATCHES


From jewelry, to watches, money clips, cuff links, tie bars, and more, Argyle Jewelers is your source for all of your men’s jewelry and gift needs.

Artboard 3 copy 6

KIDS COLLECTION


At Argyle Jewelers, we can help you select beautiful children’s jewelry appropriate for any age and occasion. Our team can assist you with finding just the right piece for that special child in your life.

Artboard 3 copy 5

FINGER PRINT JEWELRY


Fingerprint Jewelry is a new and unique way of capturing a piece of your loved one and holding them in time with a beautiful keepsake.

Why Babylon Families Trust Argyle Jewelers

Superior Service, Stunning Designs, Great Deals!


When you come to Argyle Jewelers, we make sure that your experience is nothing short of…wonderful! We specialize in custom designs and offer helpful personalized service for all budgets! All the pieces featured on our website are just some examples from what awaits inside this store and on our online shop – so if something catches your eye or someone special deserves an extra special gift, stop by soon because these things don’t last long around here…

OUR CLIENTS LOVE US

Read what they have to say!


fallback-user

Ann F

Joe is a genius! My heart didn’t skip a beat on my first choice of engagement ring and bands, he pulled out a new setting last minute and I was …

fallback-user

Jonathan W

Went to Argyle Jewelers looking for ideas for an engagement ring, and walked out with one. The Service I received was beyond fantastic. Way superior to any of the places …

fallback-user

Justine F

My boyfriend and I went to Argyle’s to purchase a ring from an online listing and wanted to ensure that the diamond was authentic. Argyle Jewelers was extremely kind and …

fallback-user

Katie R

Argyle Jewelers is the place to go to for personalized customer service and amazing custom jewellery. My husband purchased my engagement ring from Joe and he was simply the best …

fallback-user

Demetra T

What an amazing job Joe did on my engagement ring. Genuinely cared and listened to what I was looking for. He searched and found several settings to compare, then made …

Frequently Asked Questions

What services does Argyle Jewelers offer?

Argyle Jewelers offers fine jewelry, engagement rings, watches, and unique collections for men, women, and children. They also provide custom jewelry design, jewelry and watch repair, buying services, and certified jewelry appraisals.

Do you offer custom engagement ring design?

Yes. Argyle Jewelers offers custom engagement ring design, allowing customers to work with their team to create a unique ring that matches their style, diamond choice, and budget.

How long has Argyle Jewelers been in business?

Argyle Jewelers has been serving the Babylon community since 1988, providing fine jewelry, custom designs, repairs, and appraisal services for over 35 years.

What areas do you serve on Long Island?

Argyle Jewelers serves customers throughout Babylon Village, Suffolk County, and surrounding Long Island communities, helping local families with jewelry sales, custom designs, repairs, and appraisals.

Men’s Wedding Bands: A Complete Style Guide for Grooms

Choosing the right wedding band is an important decision for every groom, as it is a piece of jewelry meant to be worn every day for life. Today’s men have more options than ever, from timeless gold rings to durable modern metals like tungsten and titanium. Whether...

How to Sell Your Jewelry: Getting the Best Price on Long Island

If you are planning to sell gold jewelry on Long Island, understanding how the selling process works can help you make smarter and more profitable decisions. Whether you have inherited estate jewelry, outdated gold pieces, broken silver chains, or diamond jewelry you...

Matching Wedding Bands: Should Couples Coordinate Their Rings?

Choosing wedding rings is an important step for couples preparing for marriage. One common question couples ask is whether their wedding bands should match or if each person should choose a different style. While matching wedding bands have been a traditional choice...

Understanding Jewelry Appraisal vs. Evaluation: What’s the Difference?

Jewelry often carries both financial and emotional value. Whether you recently purchased a new piece, inherited a family heirloom, or want to insure valuable items, understanding the difference between a jewelry appraisal and a jewelry evaluation is important. Many...

Understanding the 4 Cs of Diamonds: A Babylon Buyer’s Guide

Shopping for a diamond can feel overwhelming. You walk into a jeweler, and suddenly you're hearing terms like "VS1 clarity" and "ideal cut" without much context. If you're not sure what any of it means, you're not alone. The 4 Cs of diamonds Cut, Clarity, Color, and...

Custom Engagement Rings in Babylon: Design Your Dream Ring

Every love story is distinct, filled with its own inside jokes, shared memories, and future dreams. When it comes time to symbolize that bond with an engagement ring, a mass produced piece from a display case often feels impersonal. It might be beautiful, but it...

The Ultimate Guide to Wedding Bands in Babylon, NY

The proposal is done. The champagne has been popped, and the excitement of the engagement is still bubbling. But while the engagement ring often steals the spotlight during the proposal, it is the wedding band that you exchange on your big day that acts as the...

Caring for Your Fine Jewelry: Maintenance Tips from Expert Jewelers

Your jewelry box holds more than just metal and stone. It holds memories. That vintage sapphire ring might remind you of a grandmother who loved the ocean, while a diamond tennis bracelet marks a major career milestone. These pieces are emotionally priceless. However,...

What to Look for in a Long Island Jewelry Store: A Buyer’s Checklist

Buying fine jewelry is rarely just a transaction. It is an emotional and financial investment. Whether you are searching for an engagement ring that symbolizes a lifetime of commitment or an heirloom piece to pass down to future generations, the process can feel...

Diamond vs. Gemstone Engagement Rings: Which is Right for You?

Getting engaged is one of the most exciting milestones in life, but finding the perfect ring can feel overwhelming. For generations, a diamond solitaire was the default choice for proposals. It was the standard for elegance and tradition. But times are changing....